Buying tyres is one of those purchases where there is a lot of jargon and not much plain explanation. Here is what actually matters, in the order it matters.
1. Get the size, load index and speed rating right
A tyre size looks like 205/55 R16 91V. The 205 is the width in millimetres, the 55 is the sidewall height as a percentage of that width, the R means radial and the 16 is the wheel diameter in inches.
The last two are the ones people ignore and should not. The 91 is the load index, which sets how much weight the tyre can carry. The V is the speed rating.
Both are specified by the car manufacturer for a reason. Fitting below the specified load index means the tyre is working beyond its design whenever the car is loaded, which matters on estates, MPVs and vans. Going below the specified speed rating changes how the car behaves and on some insurance policies counts as an undeclared modification. Going above either is harmless.
Easiest answer: give us the registration and we will look it all up.
2. Buy in pairs, and put them on the back
Replacing two tyres across an axle is normal and perfectly safe. The two on the same axle should match each other; front and rear do not need to match.
If you are buying two, they belong on the rear, whichever wheels drive the car. This surprises almost everyone. The reason is that a car with more grip at the front than the back is the one that swaps ends in the wet, and understeer is far easier to recover from than oversteer.
Four wheel drive cars are the exception worth flagging. A big difference in rolling circumference between axles puts continuous load through the centre differential, so on some models all four should be changed together. Tell us what the car is and we will say whether it applies.
3. Original equipment fitments
Some manufacturers specify a tyre built to their own spec, marked on the sidewall with a code such as MO, AO, * or N-rated. These are tuned to that car and can genuinely make a difference to how it rides.
They are usually dearer, and on some vehicles staying with them matters for warranty purposes. Worth checking before you decide either way rather than after.
4. Summer, winter or all season
The dividing line is about seven degrees. Below it, summer rubber stiffens and loses grip before the road is anywhere near icy. Above it, winter tyres wear quickly and feel vague.
For most people around here an all season tyre is the sensible compromise. You give up a little dry performance and a little snow performance, and in exchange you never have to think about it or store a second set.
5. The EU label, and which bit to care about
Every new tyre carries a label rating fuel economy, wet grip and noise.
Wet grip is the one that matters. The gap between an A and an E rating is several car lengths in an emergency stop on a wet road, which is precisely the situation where you find out what you bought.
Fuel economy makes a real but small difference over tens of thousands of miles. Noise matters more on a quiet car than a noisy one.
6. Budget, mid-range or premium
There is a real difference, and it is mostly wet braking and how long the tread lasts. There is also a lot of nonsense talked about it, so here is the honest version.
Everything road legal in the UK has passed the same type approval. A budget tyre from a proper manufacturer is not unsafe. What you give up is grip in the wet when the rubber is cold, and mileage, so a set that costs a third less can end up costing about the same per mile.
If you do serious motorway miles or carry a family every day, buy the better tyre. If the car is going within a year or it is a second car doing three thousand local miles, a good mid-range tyre is a perfectly rational buy and the premium set is money you do not need to spend.
How we handle it
We will not read out a list of forty names. Tell us the car, roughly what mileage you do and what sort of miles they are, and we will put two or three sensible options in front of you with prices, and say which one we would put on our own vehicle.
The price we quote includes the tyre, a new valve, fitting, balancing and taking the old one away, because those four things always happen together. Ring with the registration and we will bring them to wherever the car is parked.